An Access Control Entry (ACE) is crucial in defining access rights within computer systems. Each ACE specifies the permissions granted or denied to a user or group, identified by a unique Security Identifier (SID). 

A Security Identifier (SID) is a unique value used to identify a trustee.

These entries are the building blocks of Access Control Lists (ACLs), which aggregate multiple ACEs to outline comprehensive access policies for various resources, such as files or databases.

Definition of Access Control Entry (ACE)

An ACL is an ordered set of ACEs. This order is not arbitrary; it dictates the sequence in which the system evaluates each ACE to determine a user's effective permissions. Typically, the process stops at the first match, meaning ACEs' positioning can significantly impact access outcomes. For example, if a denied ACE appears before a granted ACE for the same resource and user, the denied ACE will take precedence, blocking access.

Components of Access Control Entry (ACE) 

Access Control Entries comprise of the following components:

  • A security identifier (SID) to uniquely identify a particular user or a group.
  • Bit flags, determining whether child objects can inherit the ACE
Bit Flag, also known as bit field, is used in programming and developing to create a data structure.
  • A flag indicating the ACE type
  • An access mask that specifies permission rights
The ACCESS_MASK data type is a DWORD value that defines standard, specific, and generic rights. These rights are used in access control entries (ACEs) and are the primary means of specifying the requested or granted access to an object.

The Scope of Access Control Entry (ACE)

Access Control Entries (ACEs) regulate all access to objects such as platforms, programs, or software by defining who can access the object and at what level to ensure the security of a certain system.

  • User Access: ACEs utilize the user's credentials and rights to log them into the system.
  • Application Access: When an application attempts to access an object, the operating system compares the app's credentials to the security control assigned in the access control list.

Types of Access Control Entries (ACEs)

There are five types of ACEs used by the security subsystem. The Type member of the ACE structure controls the interpretation of the ACE. The defined types are:

  • ACCESS_ALLOWED_ACE_TYPE‚ÄĒ: This type of ACE grants access rights to a specific SID.
  • ACCESS_DENIED_ACE_TYPE‚ÄĒ: This type indicates that the ACE specifies access rights to be denied to the specific SID.
  • SYSTEM_AUDIT_ACE_TYPE‚ÄĒ: This type indicates that the ACE specifies auditing behavior.
  • SYSTEM_ALARM_ACE_TYPE‚ÄĒ: This type indicates that the ACE specifies the behavior of the alarm.
  • ACCESS_ALLOWED_COMPOUND_ACE_TYPE‚ÄĒ: This type indicates that the ACE is associated with a specific server and the entity it represents.

Five types help manage access to an object. Three types control programmatic access, while the other two manage audit and alarm behavior when someone accesses the object. 

It's important to note that the security subsystem's behavior is determined by combining the information from one or more of the ACEs that are linked to the object.

DACL Vs. SACL

A Discretionary Access Control List (DACL) is a list that specifies which users or groups have permission to access an object and which are denied access. If a user or group is not listed in the DACL, they will be denied access. The DACL is usually managed by the owner or creator of the object to which it belongs. Each entry is called an Access Control Entry (ACE).

A System Access Control List (SACL) is a list that tells the system which users or actions should be audited when they attempt to access an object. This helps in identifying security issues and understanding the extent of damage. The owner or creator of the object usually controls the SACL by default. The Access Control Entries (ACEs) in a SACL decide whether to record failed or successful attempts when a user tries to access the object.

DACL Vs. SACL

Potential Vulnerabilities of Access Control Entry (ACE)

There are many types of vulnerabilities relevant to ACE, such as:

  • Privilege Escalation: An attacker could exploit access control entries (ACEs) vulnerabilities to gain unauthorized access to resources with excessive privileges, potentially compromising the entire system.
  • Permission Bypass: Vulnerabilities may allow unauthorized access and compromise of sensitive data by bypassing access restrictions defined by ACEs.
  • Logic Flaws: Errors in the logic used to evaluate ACEs may compromise system security by granting or denying unintended access.

Access Control Entry (ACE) Best Practices

ACE includes a thorough review and adjustment of access control lists (ACLs) to ensure that only necessary permissions are granted to users based on their roles. It also involves adhering to the principles of least privilege and role-based access control (RBAC) to limit access based on users’ roles.

Regular monitoring, auditing, and updating of ACE configurations, along with strong authentication methods and encryption, contribute to robust access control. To properly configure ACEs, it is important to follow the principle of least privilege, set strict limits on resource permissions, and use precise ACE specifications.

Automating the regular review of ACE settings for critical system components and the application of advanced ACL configurations further strengthens security and prevents privilege escalation.

Related Terms

Suggested Articles

Continue Learning